Alexey Navalny
Oh, Sergey Semyonovich, this is the eternal lie of "civil servants" - it's like a swamp.
The acting mayor of Moscow, Sergei Sobyanin, said that the apartment in the center of Moscow had long been declared in accordance with the established procedure, and the opposition's statements on this matter are speculation. “Everything has been declared for so many years already, no one hides anything. It has been in the declaration for seven years, so everything else is speculation, ”Sobyanin told reporters.
Acting press secretary of the acting mayor Gulnara Penkova confirmed that the apartment was privatized in the prescribed manner, officially declared. "This is standard practice," she pointed out. Earlier, Penkova said that the apartment in the house 12/1 on Rochdelskaya street with an area of 308 sq. m was allocated to Sobyanin by the Presidential Administration in January 2006 as the head of the presidential administration.
We are not talking about declarations here, but about the legality of receipt. So tomorrow you will declare ownership of Gorky Park, informing everyone: "The park has long been declared, so everything else is speculation."
We have already found out that civil servant Sobyanin has already once privatized an apartment in Tyumen of 116 square meters (otherwise, where did he get it from?), And you can privatize an apartment once in a lifetime.
And, in any case, an apartment on Rodchelskaya Street is either official housing that cannot be privatized, or received on social lease on extraordinary terms, which is possible if Sobyanin is an orphan, has epilepsy, or his Tyumen apartment was blown away by a hurricane.
Okay, as for the wonderful 308 square meters in the center of Moscow, then we will wait for the answers of the prosecutor's office.
It is curious, of course, what they will come up with: they will declare Sobyanin an orphan or sick with leprosy, but you just have to wait.
Well, for now, let's remember that the civil servant Sobyanin has a second daughter: Anna Sergeevna Sobyanina.
As befits the daughter of a major civil servant, she is terribly talented.
The business vein, as you know, wakes up in the children of civil servants right after their parents take office.
On October 18, 2011, 2 weeks after her 25th birthday (she was born on October 2, 1986), Anna Sergeevna Sobyanina buys an apartment in the Central District of St. Petersburg, at 14 Malaya Konyushennaya Street.
|
Now the apartment in this building has an area of 152 sq.m. is sold for 86.2 million rubles, that is, the apartment of young Anna Sergeevna is now worth about 116.6 million rubles.
This is what her house looks like:
It's beautiful, right?
Few people were lucky enough to even stay in such a house.
On the other hand, few people were lucky enough to be born the daughter of a civil servant Sobyanin.
How can a 25-year-old daughter of a civil servant, whose maximum income for the last ten years is 27 million rubles, have an apartment for 116 million rubles?
We indignantly reject the very idea that civil servant Sobyanin gave a luxurious apartment in the center of St. Petersburg to his daughter for her 25th birthday. This is so unlike civil servants!
Of course, Anna Sergeevna Sobyanina earned everything herself.
A year earlier, she became one of the founders of Forus-Group LLC.
"To exceed the highest expectations of the client."
Fabulous.
Let's quickly find out who these customers are. We go to the "Objects" section.
SUDDENLY
The building of administrative bodies (Khanty-Mansiysk)
Station block of the Government International Communications
Office of the Head of the block of the station of the Government of International Communications
And finally, my favorite part.
Greetings to Serdyukov and Vasilyeva:
Reception House of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation
 |
Meeting room in the administration building of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation
 |
The only thing missing is "JSC "Rosoboronservis". Office of the head"
WHAT AN AMAZING COINCIDENCE.
The talented daughter of the civil servant Sobyanin talentedly delivers furniture to where her father Sergei Sobyanin works in the civil service.
The interests of Anna Sobyanina's firm extend exclusively to Moscow, St. Petersburg and Khanty-Mansiysk.
And only for government facilities.
"Forus-Group" not only builds houses and renovates executive offices, but has established a separate company (called Rosinterio) and opened a production facility in Reutovo, near Moscow, which manufactures furniture for them. The corresponding price list [copy on Google Docs] is posted on the site.
We managed to find only one tender, the winner of which was the firm of Anna Sobyanina. This is a supply of elite furniture for the leadership of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug.
All other orders "Forus-Group" receives without competition. Quiet and elegant: through subcontracting.
We in the Anti-Corruption Foundation see this all the time: if you want to win a contract, immediately agree with the right subcontractor, owned by such talented children of civil servants.
One could assume that Anna Sergeevna Sobyanina simply found a rich husband.
But, apparently, and, fortunately, she married for love.
The Petersburg apartments of the daughter of the Moscow mayor were not taken away for debts due to the “absence” of the owner.
Non-payment of debts became the reason for the seizure of an apartment in St. Petersburg, owned by the daughter of Moscow Mayor Sergei Sobyanin. Immediately after that, the bailiffs referred to the "impossibility" to find her mistress. The apartment itself had already become the object of journalistic investigations before.
According to the registration extract from the USRN, 31-year-old Anna Sobyanina is still prohibited from performing any registration actions with her housing of almost 205 square meters in the house on Malaya Konyushennaya Street, in the very center of St. Petersburg. The ban was imposed by bailiffs in July 2017. They were guided by a court order dated November 25, 2016 on the collection of taxes and fees, according to the website Federal Service bailiffs.
It also states that the enforcement proceedings in the case were terminated after only a month - on August 24, 2017 in connection with the application of Article 46 of Part 1 of Clause 3 federal law"On Enforcement Proceedings". This paragraph provides that the writ of execution may be returned to the recoverer in the event that it is impossible to establish the location of the debtor or his property, or “obtain information about the presence of property belonging to him Money and other values. It is not known which of the listed provisions was applied in the Sobyanina case. It was not possible to contact Anna Sobyanina. The press service of the Moscow Mayor did not answer questions, Russiangate reports.
The fact that the arrest from the apartment is not lifted a few months after the closure enforcement proceedings, not surprisingly, such a delay occurs, explains Alexander Elizarova, lawyer at Heads Consulting. But the closure of the case under the article applicable to debtors who do not have property is rather strange, because in this case it is obvious that the debtor has an apartment, and the bailiff knows about this, since he personally imposed an injunction on it.
It can be assumed that the amount of recovery is much less than the cost of the apartment, so it was impossible to achieve its sale on account of debts, and the debtor did not have any other property, so the bailiff chose this wording, argues Elizarova.
Anna Sobyanina attracted media attention in 2013, during the campaign to elect the mayor of Moscow. The candidate for this post, Alexei Navalny, then said that the girl in St. Petersburg owns not only an apartment that, according to the oppositionist, cost 117 million rubles, or three times more than Sergei Sobyanin’s official income for ten years, but also a 33% stake in Forus Group LLC . This company was engaged in the design, construction and repair of residential and office buildings, as well as the design and creation of interior items.
Anna Sobyanina, according to SPARK, ceased to be a co-owner of Forus Group in December 2015, when Vladimir Kudryavtsev consolidated 100% of the company. He also bought a share of another co-owner - Anna Sobyanina's neighbor Vyacheslav Kalashnikov. Kudryavtsev is still listed as the sole owner of Forus Group, which has been experiencing financial difficulties since 2015: counterparties have filed claims against the company for at least 41 million rubles, follows from the database. arbitration courts.
As previously reported by the Ruspres agency, among the customers of Forus Group were the Ministry of Defense headed by Sergei Shoigu and the administration of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug, a region in which Sergei Sobyanin himself previously worked. At the same time, only the contract for the supply of furniture to the leadership of the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug was won at the tender, the rest of the orders were carried out without a tender at all. After the appearance of the relevant publications, information about the contracts disappeared from the Forus Group website, but references to contracts can be found on public procurement websites.
August 14th, 2013
The eldest daughter of Sergei Sobyanin, Anna, settled in a prestigious district of St. Petersburg six years before receiving elite housing as a property. This happened thanks to a real estate company well-known in the Northern capital and Tyumen, the St. Petersburg media found out, trying to figure out the questions voiced by Alexei Navalny claims to the Acting Mayor of Moscow and his family.
According to "Business Petersburg", Anna Sobyanina received a residence permit in one of the apartments at number 14 on Malaya Konyushennaya Street back in 2005, when she had just arrived from Tyumen to enter the "Fly" - the Academy. Stieglitz. The girl studied there at the Department of Interior and Equipment, having defended a diploma about the interiors of restaurants in the Grand Canyon shopping mall. Recall that Navalny said that
Anna Sobyanina is one of the founders of Forus Group LLC, which is engaged in furniture trade and supplies interiors to office buildings. Meanwhile, according to Delovoy Peterburg, Anna had a small IP even before Forus.
LLC "Forus-Group" was established in 2010. As writes "Fontanka.ru", the serious success of the newly organized company, most likely, can be explained by the composition of the founders, to whom the parents transferred the ability to run the construction business. Forus Group belongs in equal shares to three young people: Anna Sobyanina - 26 years old, Vyacheslav Kalashnikov from St. Petersburg - 29 years old, to CEO Vitaly Ionin, a native of Tyumen, is 31 years old. By a strange coincidence, they are all neighbors at 14 Malaya Konyushennaya. All three are registered in the same apartment in the building at Malaya Konyushennaya, 14, and Ekaterina Burilova became the fourth in this company.
The apartment with an area of 204.9 square meters, which is referred to in Navalny's revealing article, Anna Sobyanina, presumably, was purchased from Vladimir Kalashnikov's namesake (or relative) Valentina Kalashnikova, Delovoy Peterburg writes. In any case, in some bases, it is the latter that is still listed as the owner, although according to Sobyanin's Rosreestr, he has owned housing since 2011.
As Fontanka.ru adds, Forus is very closely associated with one of the largest real estate companies in Russia, Advex: Vyacheslav Kalashnikov is the son of one of the owners of Advex, Olga Kalashnikova. Anna Sobyanina is also not a stranger to Advex, since almost from the moment she arrived in St. Petersburg from Tyumen, she was permanently registered at the place of residence in house 14 on Malaya Konyushennaya, in an apartment owned by LLC TFK (subsidiary of Advex). According to Delovoy Peterburg, Vladimir Kalashnikov is related to five more apartments in this building: some belong to him, some to his mother, and some to LLC TFK, which belongs to him.
The DP also found out that at the same address as Forus-Group, on Nevsky, 146, the company "Monbelier St. Petersburg" is registered - a branch of the company with branches in the Sverdlovsk and Chelyabinsk regions, as well as in Moscow, engaged in furniture trade . The co-owner of "Monbelier" is Evgenia Burilova (apparently, the mother of the inhabitant of Malaya Konyushennaya, 14, too), in Tyumen she also had a business organizing holidays on ships.
Recall that after Alexei Navalny asked yesterday how Sobyanin's 25-year-old daughter could get an apartment in the center of St. Petersburg worth more than 100 million rubles, husband of Anna Sobyanina Alexander Ershov said that he earned it and bought expensive housing. Meanwhile, Navalny doubted this, since, according to his data, the young man was not noticed "in any entrepreneurial activity." The St. Petersburg media have not yet found any mention of Yershov in connection with the acquisition of the scandalous apartment.
The press secretary of the Acting Mayor of Moscow, Gulnara Penkova, commented sparingly on radio stations the night before "Echo of Moscow" the situation with a new portion of compromising evidence published by Alexei Navalny. "Sergey Sobyanin's daughter Anna has long been an adult, married, lives in St. Petersburg," said a representative of the mayor. "Sergey Sobyanin had nothing to do with their joint apartment," Penkova also noted.
As befits the daughter of a major civil servant, she is terribly talented, rich and simply beautiful. According to the old tradition, before the elections of the mayor, they begin to throw mud at the candidates. Here is another stuffing on the daughter of one of the candidates for mayor of Moscow.
Student of the St. Petersburg Art and Industry Academy. A.L. Stieglitz. She was born on October 2, 1986. She studied at gymnasium No. 1 and the children's art school of Khanty-Mansiysk. In 2003 she entered the full-time department of the faculty of monumental art of the St. Petersburg State Academy of Art and Industry named after. A.L. Stieglitz. Dreams of becoming a designer, loves the work of Dima Bilan. Lives in St. Petersburg.
After her 25th birthday, Anna Sergeevna Sobyanina either bought or gave her dad an apartment in the Central District of St. Petersburg, at 14 Malaya Konyushennaya Street.
Even if you have never been to St. Petersburg, then the names of the neighboring objects "Marsovo Pole", "Nevsky Prospekt", "Palace Square", which everyone has seen in books a million times, speak for themselves - this is a great place. VERY EXPENSIVE .
The area of the apartment of the daughter of a civil servant Anna Sobyanina is 204.9 sq.m.
And here is her beloved daddy, who pampers her with expensive gifts:
Now the apartment in this building has an area of 152 sq.m. is sold for 86.2 million rubles, that is, the apartment of young Anna Sergeevna is now worth about 116.6 million rubles.
This is what her house looks like:
Beautiful, right? Few people were lucky enough to even stay in such a house. On the other hand, few were lucky enough to be born the daughter of a civil servant Sobyanin. Where did the 25-year-old daughter of a civil servant, whose maximum income ten recent years 27 million rubles, maybe an apartment for 116 million rubles?
We indignantly reject the very idea that civil servant Sobyanin gave a luxurious apartment in the center of St. Petersburg to his daughter for her 25th birthday. This is so unlike civil servants! Of course, Anna Sergeevna Sobyanina earned everything herself. A year earlier, she became one of the founders of Forus-Group LLC.
The talented daughter of the civil servant Sobyanin talentedly delivers furniture to where her father Sergei Sobyanin works in the civil service.
The interests of Anna Sobyanina's firm extend exclusively to Moscow, St. Petersburg and Khanty-Mansiysk. And exclusively to state facilities.
"Forus-Group" not only builds houses and renovates executive offices, but has established a separate company (called Rosinterio) and opened a production facility in Reutovo, near Moscow, which manufactures furniture for them.
WHAT AN AMAZING COINCIDENCE.
Meeting room of the President of the Russian Federation
Meeting room in the administration building of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation
Engineering and household complex (Khanty-Mansiysk)
Conference hall
13.08.2013, 09:38
Oh, Sergey Semyonovich, this is the eternal lie of "civil servants" - it's like a swamp.
The acting mayor of Moscow, Sergei Sobyanin, said that the apartment in the center of Moscow had long been declared in accordance with the established procedure, and the opposition's statements on this matter are speculation. “Everything has been declared for so many years already, no one hides anything. It has been in the declaration for seven years, so everything else is speculation,” Sobyanin told reporters.
Acting press secretary of the Acting Mayor Gulnara Penkova confirmed that the apartment was duly privatized and officially declared. "This is standard practice," she pointed out. Earlier, Penkova said that the apartment in the house 12/1 on Rochdelskaya street with an area of 308 sq. m was allocated to Sobyanin by the Presidential Administration in January 2006 as the head of the presidential administration.
http://www.vedomosti.ru/politi...
We are not talking about declarations here, but about the legality of receipt. So tomorrow you will declare ownership of Gorky Park, informing everyone: "The park has long been declared, so everything else is speculation."
Okay, as for the wonderful 308 square meters in the center of Moscow, we will wait for the answers of the prosecutor's office.
It is curious, of course, what they will come up with: they will declare Sobyanin an orphan or sick with leprosy, but you just have to wait.
Well, for now, let's remember that the civil servant Sobyanin has a second daughter: Anna Sergeevna Sobyanina.
As befits the daughter of a major civil servant, she is terribly talented.
The business vein, as you know, wakes up in the children of civil servants right after their parents take office.
October 18, 2011 2 weeks after his 25th birthday (She was born on October 2, 1986), Anna Sergeevna Sobyanina buys an apartment in the Central District of St. Petersburg, at 14 Malaya Konyushennaya Street.
Even if you have never been to St. Petersburg, the names of the neighboring objects "Marsovo Pole", "Nevsky Prospekt", "Palace Square", which everyone has seen in books a million times, speak for themselves - this is a great place.
VERY EXPENSIVE.
The area of the apartment of the daughter of a civil servant Anna Sobyanina is 204.9 sq.m.
Now the apartment in this building has an area of 152 sq.m. is on sale for 86.2 million rubles, that is, the apartment of young Anna Sergeevna is now worth about 116.6 million .
This is what her house looks like:
It's beautiful, right?
Few people were lucky enough to even stay in such a house.
On the other hand, few people were lucky enough to be born the daughter of a civil servant Sobyanin.
How can a 25-year-old daughter of a civil servant, whose maximum income for the last ten years is 27 million rubles, have an apartment for 116 million rubles?
We indignantly reject the very idea that civil servant Sobyanin gave a luxurious apartment in the center of St. Petersburg to his daughter for her 25th birthday. This is so unlike civil servants!
Of course, Anna Sergeevna Sobyanina earned everything herself.
"Exceed the highest customer expectations".
Fabulous.
Let's quickly find out who these customers are. We go to the section " Objects".
And finally, my favorite part.
Greetings to Serdyukov and Vasilyeva:
The only thing missing is " JSC "Rosoboronservis". Head office "
WHAT AN AMAZING COINCIDENCE.
The talented daughter of the civil servant Sobyanin talentedly delivers furniture to where her father Sergei Sobyanin works in the civil service.
The interests of Anna Sobyanina's firm extend exclusively to Moscow, St. Petersburg and Khanty-Mansiysk.
And only for government facilities.
"Forus-Group" not only builds houses and renovates executive offices, but has established a separate company (called Rosinterio) and opened a production facility in Reutovo, near Moscow, which manufactures furniture for them. Corresponding price list \[copy on Google Docs] posted on the site.
Here is a short excerpt:
We managed to find only one tender, the winner of which was the firm of Anna Sobyanina. This is a supply of elite furniture for the leadership of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug.
All other orders "Forus-Group" receives without competition. Quiet and elegant: through subcontracting.
We in the Anti-Corruption Foundation see this all the time: if you want to win a contract, immediately agree with the right subcontractor, owned by such talented children of civil servants.
One could assume that Anna Sergeevna Sobyanina simply found a rich husband.
But, apparently, and, fortunately, she married for love.
her husband (
